Technical Articles & Tutorials

The Visual Basic Gap: What Modern Web Development is Still Missing

For developers who worked with Visual Basic in the 1990s and early 2000s, there's often a sense that despite all the advances in web technologies, something fundamental has been lost. The speed, consistency, and visual development paradigm of VB allowed developers to build applications with unprecedented efficiency. This article explores the "Visual Basic gap" in modern web development, focusing on how frameworks like Django and Bootstrap attempt to fill it, while identifying what's still missing from the ideal developer experience.

The Visual Basic Productivity Model

To understand what we're missing, let's recall what made Visual Basic so revolutionary:

Key Visual Basic Productivity Features
  • Visual Form Designer: Truly WYSIWYG interface building
  • Properties Panel: Universal configuration for all components
  • Standard Controls: Consistent UI elements with predictable behavior
  • Event Wiring: Double-click to add event handlers
  • Rapid Application Development: From design to runtime with one button
  • Integrated Documentation: Context-sensitive help at the component level
  • Design-Time Support: Components look and behave in the designer as they do at runtime
The Resulting Benefits
  • Consistency: Applications had familiar patterns
  • Reduced Learning Curve: New developers could be productive quickly
  • Prototyping Speed: Functional UIs in minutes, not hours
  • Focus on Business Logic: Less boilerplate, more unique value
  • Accessibility: Non-specialists could build working applications
  • Standardization: Reduced reinvention of basic components
  • Maintenance Efficiency: Easier to understand and modify

In web development, we've regained much of this functionality through various frameworks and libraries, but the experience remains fragmented and often requires specialized knowledge across multiple domains.

Django's Component Model: The Backend Perspective

Django, a Python web framework, provides several features that resemble Visual Basic's component model, but primarily from a backend perspective:

Django Forms and Widgets

Django forms offer a declarative way to define form fields and validation rules, somewhat similar to placing controls on a Visual Basic form:

# Django form definition
from django import forms

class ContactForm(forms.Form):
    name = forms.CharField(max_length=100, required=True, label='Your Name')
    email = forms.EmailField(required=True, help_text='We will never share your email')
    message = forms.CharField(widget=forms.Textarea, required=True)
    priority = forms.ChoiceField(choices=[
        ('low', 'Low Priority'),
        ('medium', 'Medium Priority'),
        ('high', 'High Priority'),
    ], initial='medium')
    attachment = forms.FileField(required=False)
    subscribe = forms.BooleanField(required=False, label='Subscribe to newsletter')

# Then in a view
def contact_view(request):
    if request.method == 'POST':
        form = ContactForm(request.POST, request.FILES)
        if form.is_valid():
            # Process form data
            send_email(form.cleaned_data)
            return redirect('thank_you')
    else:
        form = ContactForm()
    
    return render(request, 'contact.html', {'form': form})

This declarative approach provides some of the benefits of Visual Basic's design-time components:

  • Standardized field types (text, email, file, etc.)
  • Integrated validation
  • Field configuration through parameters (somewhat like a properties panel)
  • Automatic HTML generation

But unlike Visual Basic, there's no visual editor - all configuration is done in code.

Django Admin: The Closest to "Visual Basic for Data"

Django's admin interface is perhaps the closest equivalent to Visual Basic's productivity model in modern web development:

# models.py - Define your data model
from django.db import models

class Product(models.Model):
    name = models.CharField(max_length=100)
    description = models.TextField()
    price = models.DecimalField(max_digits=10, decimal_places=2)
    in_stock = models.BooleanField(default=True)
    created_at = models.DateTimeField(auto_now_add=True)
    
    def __str__(self):
        return self.name

# admin.py - Register with the admin interface
from django.contrib import admin
from .models import Product

@admin.register(Product)
class ProductAdmin(admin.ModelAdmin):
    list_display = ('name', 'price', 'in_stock', 'created_at')
    list_filter = ('in_stock', 'created_at')
    search_fields = ('name', 'description')
    fieldsets = (
        ('Basic Information', {
            'fields': ('name', 'price', 'in_stock')
        }),
        ('Details', {
            'fields': ('description',),
            'classes': ('collapse',)
        }),
    )

This small amount of code generates a complete CRUD interface for managing products, with:

  • List views with sorting and filtering
  • Detail forms with field grouping
  • Search functionality
  • Validation based on the model definition

The Django admin demonstrates what's possible when frameworks prioritize component standardization and rapid development. With minimal code, you get a functional application - much like the Visual Basic philosophy.

Template Components in Django

Django's template system provides ways to create reusable components through includes and template tags:



{% if card_header %}
{{ card_header }}
{% endif %}
{{ card_content }} {% if card_footer_content %} {% endif %}
{% include "components/card.html" with card_header="User Profile" card_content=user_profile_html card_class="mb-4" %} {% load component_tags %} {% card header="Product Details" content=product_details_html footer=product_actions class="mb-3" %}

While this approach allows for component reuse, it lacks the visual design capabilities and properties panel of Visual Basic. Developers must write HTML and understand the template language rather than working with visual components.

Bootstrap: Standardized UI Components

Bootstrap provides a standardized set of UI components that helps to address the consistency aspect of the Visual Basic experience:

Bootstrap's Component Library

Bootstrap includes dozens of pre-styled components that can be used consistently across projects:

<!-- A standard Bootstrap card component -->
<div class="card">
  <div class="card-header">
    Featured
  </div>
  <div class="card-body">
    <h5 class="card-title">Special title treatment</h5>
    <p class="card-text">With supporting text below as a natural lead-in to additional content.</p>
    <a href="#" class="btn btn-primary">Go somewhere</a>
  </div>
</div>

<!-- Bootstrap modal component -->
<div class="modal" tabindex="-1">
  <div class="modal-dialog">
    <div class="modal-content">
      <div class="modal-header">
        <h5 class="modal-title">Modal title</h5>
        <button type="button" class="btn-close" data-bs-dismiss="modal" aria-label="Close"></button>
      </div>
      <div class="modal-body">
        <p>Modal body text goes here.</p>
      </div>
      <div class="modal-footer">
        <button type="button" class="btn btn-secondary" data-bs-dismiss="modal">Close</button>
        <button type="button" class="btn btn-primary">Save changes</button>
      </div>
    </div>
  </div>
</div>

Bootstrap components provide:

  • Consistent appearance across projects
  • Responsive design built-in
  • Familiar patterns for users
  • Documented behaviors and options

However, unlike Visual Basic controls, Bootstrap components must be manually coded in HTML. There's no drag-and-drop editor or properties panel (though some third-party tools attempt to provide this functionality).

Bootstrap Customization System

Bootstrap provides a systematic way to customize components through variables, somewhat similar to Visual Basic's property system:

// SCSS customization of Bootstrap
$primary: #3273dc;
$secondary: #d9e6fc;
$success: #48c774;
$info: #3298dc;
$warning: #ffdd57;
$danger: #f14668;

$enable-gradients: true;
$enable-shadows: true;
$border-radius: .25rem;
$btn-border-radius: $border-radius;

// Import Bootstrap after variable overrides
@import "bootstrap/scss/bootstrap";

This provides a centralized way to customize the appearance of components across an entire application, but:

  • It requires understanding of SCSS/CSS
  • There's no immediate visual feedback when making changes
  • Changes apply globally rather than to individual component instances
Integrating Django and Bootstrap: Getting Closer to the Visual Basic Experience

When Django and Bootstrap are integrated, we get closer to the Visual Basic ideal of rapid application development with standardized components:

Django + Bootstrap Form Rendering

Using packages like django-crispy-forms or django-bootstrap5, we can automatically render Django forms with Bootstrap styling:

# Install with: pip install django-crispy-forms crispy-bootstrap5

# settings.py
INSTALLED_APPS = [
    # ...
    'crispy_forms',
    'crispy_bootstrap5',
]

CRISPY_ALLOWED_TEMPLATE_PACKS = "bootstrap5"
CRISPY_TEMPLATE_PACK = "bootstrap5"


{% load crispy_forms_tags %}

{% csrf_token %} {{ form|crispy }}

This integration helps to standardize form appearance and behavior, making the development experience more predictable. However, there are still limitations compared to Visual Basic:

  • No direct manipulation of form layout in a visual designer
  • Limited ability to customize individual instances of form fields
  • No built-in event handling system (requires custom JavaScript)
Creating Reusable Django + Bootstrap Components

For more complex components, we can create custom template tags that combine Django functionality with Bootstrap styling:

# In a file called templatetags/component_tags.py
from django import template
from django.utils.safestring import mark_safe

register = template.Library()

@register.simple_tag
def bootstrap_alert(message, alert_type="info", dismissible=True):
    """Render a Bootstrap alert component with the given message and type."""
    dismiss_button = ""
    if dismissible:
        dismiss_button = ''
        class_attr = f'class="alert alert-{alert_type} alert-dismissible fade show"'
    else:
        class_attr = f'class="alert alert-{alert_type}"'
        
    return mark_safe(f'''
    
{message} {dismiss_button}
''')


{% load component_tags %}

{% bootstrap_alert "Your profile has been updated successfully!" alert_type="success" %}
{% bootstrap_alert "Please check your input and try again." alert_type="danger" %}
{% bootstrap_alert "This feature is still in beta." alert_type="warning" dismissible=False %}

This approach allows for:

  • Consistent component usage across templates
  • Parameterized customization (somewhat like a properties panel)
  • Encapsulated behavior

However, this still relies entirely on code, without the visual design capabilities that made Visual Basic so productive.

Django Class-Based Views + Bootstrap: Component-Like Page Templates

Django's class-based views, combined with Bootstrap layouts, can create reusable "page components" that offer some of the benefits of Visual Basic forms:

# views.py
from django.views.generic import CreateView, UpdateView, DetailView, ListView
from .models import Product
from .forms import ProductForm

class ProductCreateView(CreateView):
    model = Product
    form_class = ProductForm
    template_name = 'products/product_form.html'
    success_url = '/products/'

class ProductListView(ListView):
    model = Product
    template_name = 'products/product_list.html'
    context_object_name = 'products'
    paginate_by = 10
    
    def get_queryset(self):
        queryset = super().get_queryset()
        search_term = self.request.GET.get('search', '')
        if search_term:
            queryset = queryset.filter(name__icontains=search_term)
        return queryset


{% extends "base.html" %}

{% block content %}
Products
Add Product
{% for product in products %} {% empty %} {% endfor %}
Name Price In Stock Actions
{{ product.name }} ${{ product.price }} {% if product.in_stock %}Yes{% else %}No{% endif %} View Edit
No products found.
{% if is_paginated %} {% endif %}
{% endblock %}

This combination provides:

  • Consistent CRUD interfaces across the application
  • Reusable page patterns
  • Standard behavior for common operations

While powerful, this approach still requires significant manual coding for both the Python view logic and the HTML templates, unlike Visual Basic's visual design experience.

What's Still Missing: The Visual Basic Gap

Despite the power of Django and Bootstrap, several key aspects of the Visual Basic development experience remain absent in modern web development:

Missing Visual Design Capabilities
  • True WYSIWYG Editor: No mainstream way to visually design pages with immediate feedback
  • Drag-and-Drop Interface: Can't position elements visually
  • Component Properties Panel: No universal way to inspect and modify component properties
  • Design-Time Preview: Limited ability to see how components will look with actual data
Missing Component Infrastructure
  • Universal Component Model: No standard way to define components across frameworks
  • Visual Event Wiring: No visual way to connect events to handlers
  • Integrated Development Experience: Design, code, and data separate in most tools
  • Component Marketplace: No universal ecosystem of plug-and-play components

The result of these gaps is that web development, despite all its advances, still requires substantially more coding and technical knowledge than Visual Basic did for comparable functionality. The productivity promise of drag-and-drop design with standardized components remains largely unfulfilled in mainstream web development.

Attempts to Fill the Gap

Several projects have attempted to bring Visual Basic-like capabilities to web development:

Approach Examples Strengths Limitations
Visual Page Builders Webflow, Wix Editor X, Bubble True visual design, immediate feedback, integrated components Limited integration with traditional development workflows, vendor lock-in, performance trade-offs
Low-Code Platforms Microsoft Power Apps, OutSystems, Mendix Visual design for business apps, integrated data model, rapid development Enterprise pricing, limited customization, proprietary ecosystem
Django Admin Customization django-grappelli, django-jet, django-admin-interface Enhances Django admin with more advanced UI features, maintains Django's data-driven approach Limited to admin interfaces, not general-purpose, still requires coding for customization
React Component Editors Plasmic, Builder.io, Framer Visual editing of React components, code export, design integration React-specific, limited backend integration, complexity in real-world projects
UI Component Frameworks Tailwind UI, Material UI, Chakra UI Comprehensive component libraries, consistent design, extensive documentation Still requires manual coding, no visual editor, framework-specific
Web Components Lit, Stencil, FAST Standard-based, framework-agnostic, encapsulated components Limited ecosystem, no visual tools, requires JavaScript expertise

While each of these approaches addresses some aspects of the Visual Basic experience, none has fully recreated the seamless visual development environment that made VB so productive.

What Would a Modern "Visual Basic for Web" Look Like?

Imagining an ideal solution that combines the best of Visual Basic with modern web capabilities:

Core Features
  • True Visual Editor: WYSIWYG design with responsive preview
  • Universal Component Model: Standard components usable across projects
  • Properties Panel: Visual configuration of component options
  • Data Binding: Visual connections between data models and UI
  • Event System: Visual wiring of events to handlers
  • Form Designer: Layout tools with automatic responsive behavior
  • Integrated Data Designer: Visual model creation and relationships
Modern Enhancements
  • Standard-Based Output: Clean HTML, CSS, and JavaScript
  • Framework Integration: Works with Django, React, Vue, etc.
  • Code Roundtripping: Visual changes reflect in code and vice versa
  • Responsive Design Tools: Visual breakpoint editing
  • Collaborative Editing: Multi-user design capabilities
  • Version Control Integration: Component changes tracked in Git
  • Component Marketplace: Ecosystem of plug-and-play elements
A Django-Centric Vision

If we were to build a "Django Studio" that embraced the Visual Basic paradigm, it might look like:

  • Integrated model designer that generates Django models
  • Visual form builder that outputs Django forms
  • Page designer with drag-and-drop Bootstrap components
  • Properties panel for adjusting component attributes
  • Event wiring that generates Django view code
  • Template visual editor that maintains compatibility with Django template language
  • Preview mode with live data from development database
  • Export to standard Django project structure

Such a tool would dramatically accelerate Django development while maintaining the framework's strengths in data modeling and admin functionality.

Practical Steps Today: Getting Closer to the Visual Basic Experience

While we wait for the ideal solution, here are practical ways to enhance your Django + Bootstrap workflow to be more "Visual Basic-like":

Component Standardization
  1. Create a component library with Django template includes
  2. Document components with examples and configuration options
  3. Build custom template tags for complex components
  4. Use django-crispy-forms with custom layouts
  5. Consider django-widget-tweaks for fine-grained control
Development Acceleration
  1. Use Django's class-based views extensively
  2. Create custom mixins for common functionality
  3. Build custom management commands to generate boilerplate
  4. Use django-extensions for development tools
  5. Consider cookiecutter templates for new projects
Visual Enhancement
  1. Use Bootstrap Studio for initial layout design
  2. Implement hot reloading with django-browser-reload
  3. Create a component showcase in your project
  4. Use Storybook for component development
  5. Consider django-debug-toolbar for live inspection

By combining these approaches, you can create a more streamlined development workflow that captures some of the efficiency of the Visual Basic experience, while still leveraging the power of modern web technologies.

Conclusion

The "Visual Basic gap" in web development represents a significant opportunity for innovation. While frameworks like Django and Bootstrap have brought standardization and productivity improvements to web development, the fully integrated visual development experience remains elusive.

Modern web development still requires too much manual coding for standard UI components and interactions that Visual Basic developers could implement with a few mouse clicks. The industry's focus on flexibility and customization has come at the cost of the standardization and productivity that made Visual Basic so powerful for business application development.

As we look to the future, the challenge is clear: how can we combine the best of Visual Basic's productivity model with the power and flexibility of modern web technologies? The team that solves this problem will unlock enormous productivity gains for web developers everywhere.

Until then, we'll continue to piece together frameworks, libraries, and tools in an attempt to recreate what Visual Basic developers took for granted over two decades ago—a truly visual, component-based development environment that lets developers focus on solving business problems rather than wrestling with implementation details.

About

Why fear those copying you, if you are doing good they will do the same to the world.

Archives

  1. AI & Automation
  2. AI Filtering for Web Content
  3. Web Fundamentals & Infrastructure
  4. Reclaiming Connection: Decentralized Social Networks
  5. Web Economics & Discovery
  6. The Broken Discovery Machine
  7. Evolution of Web Links
  8. Code & Frameworks
  9. Breaking the Tech Debt Avoidance Loop
  10. Evolution of Scaling & High Availability
  11. Evolution of Configuration & Environment
  12. Evolution of API Support
  13. Evolution of Browser & Client Support
  14. Evolution of Deployment & DevOps
  15. Evolution of Real-time Capabilities
  16. The Visual Basic Gap in Web Development
  17. Evolution of Testing & Monitoring
  18. Evolution of Internationalization & Localization
  19. Evolution of Form Processing
  20. Evolution of Security
  21. Evolution of Caching
  22. Evolution of Data Management
  23. Evolution of Response Generation
  24. Evolution of Request Routing & Handling
  25. Evolution of Session & State Management
  26. Web Framework Responsibilities
  27. Evolution of Internet Clients
  28. Evolution of Web Deployment
  29. The Missing Architectural Layer in Web Development
  30. Development Velocity Gap: WordPress vs. Modern Frameworks
  31. Data & Storage
  32. Evolution of Web Data Storage
  33. Information Management
  34. Managing Tasks Effectively: A Complete System
  35. Managing Appointments: Designing a Calendar System
  36. Building a Personal Knowledge Base
  37. Contact Management in the Digital Age
  38. Project Management for Individuals
  39. The Art of Response: Communicating with Purpose
  40. Strategic Deferral: Purposeful Postponement
  41. The Art of Delegation: Amplifying Impact
  42. Taking Action: Guide to Decisive Execution
  43. The Art of Deletion: Digital Decluttering
  44. Digital Filing: A Clutter-Free Life
  45. Managing Incoming Information
  46. Cloud & Infrastructure
  47. AWS Lightsail versus EC2
  48. WordPress on AWS Lightsail
  49. Migrating from Heroku to Dokku
  50. Storage & Media
  51. Vultr Object Storage on Django Wagtail
  52. Live Video Streaming with Nginx
  53. YI 4k Live Streaming
  54. Tools & Connectivity
  55. Multi Connection VPN
  56. Email Forms with AWS Lambda
  57. Static Sites with Hexo

Optimize Your Website!

Is your WordPress site running slowly? I offer a comprehensive service that includes needs assessments and performance optimizations. Get your site running at its best!

Check Out My Fiverr Gig!

Elsewhere

  1. YouTube
  2. Twitter
  3. GitHub